Vox Populi

A Public Sphere for Poetry, Politics, and Nature

Jill Richardson: We are all in this together

Why we can’t be okay with other people bearing the brunt of a pandemic or recession.

Western medicine is predicated on the “germ theory of disease.” That’s what it sounds like: the theory that germs like bacteria and viruses cause disease.

If you want to prevent disease, our standard theory goes, you prevent exposure to germs, or you vaccinate. If you want to cure disease, you kill the pathogens with a drug or keep the patient well enough that their immune system can fight it off.

All of that is, of course, correct. However, there’s another way to look at disease.

By the mid-1800s, John H. Griscom, an educator who was also an anti-poverty activist, noticed something. Griscom noticed that diseases that were caused by germs had a disproportionate impact on the poor. So he advocated policies to promote social welfare, like reducing rent or improving working conditions, in order to advance public health.

In this view, people can’t keep away from germs on their own — not if they also need to work for a living. And when different people catch the same germs, the outcomes can vary wildly depending on their economic fortunes in life.

America should have listened.

Instead, we ended up with public health policies that placed responsibility on individuals, keeping the focus solely on killing germs or preventing their spread. We didn’t do nearly enough about the other cause, poverty.

So, now, here we are. This disease is going to hit the rich and the poor differently.

Among the top 25 percent of earners, most have paid sick leave, nearly two-thirds have paid vacation, and over six in ten can work from home. Among the bottom 25 percent, less than half get sick leave, less than a quarter get paid vacation, and less than one in ten can work from home.

Schools have closed. Consider who has childcare and who can’t afford it? Who has health insurance and who doesn’t? With many workplaces shutting down altogether, who can afford to stay home without pay — and who can’t?

Or, how can someone whose water was shut off because they couldn’t afford their water bill wash their hands as recommended? Then consider people who are even more marginalized: the homeless, people in jails and prisons, and people in immigrant detention centers.

We’re all in this together, but we aren’t all going to be harmed equally by it.

Maybe that’s fine for some people. Maybe some people don’t mind if other people suffer so long as they and their loved ones are okay. But we’re all interconnected. Some people are disproportionately harmed, it’s true, but we’re going to rise and fall together.

If millions of people less fortunate than you get sick, their germs will spread, making the pandemic worse in a way that affects everyone.

They will overwhelm the healthcare system as has happened in Italy, and doctors will need to make choices about who lives and who dies. People who are sick from other causes will be impacted too, because they’ll be competing for the same scarce resources.

The economic fallout from this will harm all of us, too. The people who lose paychecks or jobs in this pandemic will be unable to buy what they need. That obviously hurts them, but it also hurts the entire economy.

We need to stop telling one another to pull ourselves up by our bootstraps, or blaming the unfortunate for their own plight. We need to start governing like we’re all in this together — because we are.


OtherWords columnist Jill Richardson is pursuing a PhD in sociology at the University of Wisconsin-Madison.

Distributed by OtherWords.org.

Shutterstock

5 comments on “Jill Richardson: We are all in this together

  1. ShiraDest
    March 26, 2020

    Thank you, Vox, for this post. I think many people who have never had to wonder where the next meal or evening’s shelter was going to come from have difficulty understanding the impact of poverty on health, and lack any concept of the impact of childhood resources (or lack thereof) on getting out of poverty. Blaming people who began life in a hole does not help, but it seems to be what society in general is taught to do.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Rio
    March 26, 2020

    Lots of people like to blame others for their situations because it is easy, rich or poor, but as individuals we do have to answer for our choices, probably the poor do more than the rich. But if we as individuals live with out being selfish but also with thoughtfulness (not taking the easy way) we tend to make better choices. These things include being a good friend, a good neighbor, a good citizen.
    At times this means suffering and sacrifice, probably less than we should and still a bit more than we think we can, so as not make the bad choices to get trapped in addiction or thinking you have to hoard your money or whatever. When you are poor bad choices have exaggerated and obvious effects. (I have found there is an equal number of selfish bastards hurting others in every social group, rich, poor and middle class, the differences are in the repercussions of the harm they do.)
    Social structures and laws should support any positive changes people can make in their lives and limit the negatives.
    All of us need to remember that a society is only as strong as it’s commitment to protect the weakest. If greed becomes your measure, you will find you will never have enough money to be safe or happy.
    Yes we want to be free, but freedom is not getting away with acting like children , nor making excuses or blaming others. It is having an opportunity to make our lives matter, to make sacrifices and see benefit, to have our best efforts work for the benefit of all of us.

    Liked by 2 people

  3. stitchedinstone
    March 25, 2020

    UG… this is a terribly oversimplified essay. I understand you wanting to blame the rich for eating the poor. But this is a rotten example of such things. Yes, it comes from the gut reaction. But NO it’s not particularly TRUE.
    Yes, the pandemic is going to spread among the homeless population. YES.
    YES we will all become sick.
    YES.

    Like

  4. dodadagohuhsgi
    March 24, 2020

    We are finally very similar creatures, making all too similar journeys. There is no “them.”–Tom Reilly

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Enter your email address to follow Vox Populi and receive new posts by email.

Join 11,064 other followers

Blog Stats

  • 3,863,772 hits

Archives

%d bloggers like this: